News Sections
Safeguard In The News
Safeguard Properties Promotes Five Staffers to New Positions
more
Media American Banker "Seizing the Wrong Home: Rare, But a PR Nightmare"
more
Managing REO "Confusion Mounting over PTFA"
more
ACA Sections
Hot Topics
FEMA
Property Preservation
Code Compliance
HUD
VA
Freddie Mac
Fannie Mae
Hurricane Katrina
Subscribe

Receive the latest All Client Alerts in your inbox. Click here to subscribe!

RSS NEWSFEED
RSS Safeguard's All Client Alerts, delivered to your desktop.
HUD ML 2008-31 2008 Update of Preservation and Protection Guidelines, and Cost Reimbursements
Friday, 17 October 2008
The Dept. Of Housing and Urban Development has released Mortgagee Letter (ML) 2008-31 titled "2008 Update of Preservation and Protection Guidelines, and Cost Reimbursements".

This Mortgagee Letter supersedes Mortgagee Letter 2007-03 in its entirety.  The purpose of this Mortgagee Letter is to update and clarify existing policy on preservation and protection provisions, referencing changes related to photographs, debris removal, inspections, over-allowable requests, second bids, repair of heating systems, winterization, permits and vacant property registration

This Mortgagee Letter is comprised of a General Guidance Section and ten (10) attachments.  In addition to the aforementioned changes, the HUD forms (i.e., Form HUD-9519-A, Form HUD-50012, Form HUD-50002 and Form HUD-27011) referenced in this Mortgagee Letter is now PDF fill-able. 

The effective date for policy changes and clarifications announced in this Mortgagee Letter is October 16, 2008.

The preservation and protection guidance updates are as follows: 

Photographs
Mortgagee Letter 2007-03 provided, “If photographs cannot be produced at the time of the claim review, all unsupported expenses beyond allowable cost limits will be disallowed, and for evictions, all expenses claimed for personal property/debris removal will be disallowed.”  This Mortgagee Letter provides clarification to this guideline to eliminate payment of allowable expenses without documentation.  The guideline is revised as follows.   

If photographs cannot be produced at the time of the claim review, the following will be disallowed:

  • All unsupported expenses
  • All expenses claimed for personal property/debris removal including evictions. 

Debris Removal (Dump Receipts)
Mortgagee Letter 2007-03 provided in Attachment 5, Section I, paragraph 2 that mortgagees must maintain “dump fee receipts” in order to claim reimbursement for debris removal. HUD's allowable fee for debris removal is based on the number of cubic yards of debris handled and provides reimbursement for all costs incurred in the removal including:  mileage costs incurred in traveling to the property, labor to load the debris, mileage costs incurred to deliver the debris to the disposition facility and any fee the disposal facility might charge.

The Department acknowledges that it is a common business practice of many property preservation contractors to wait until they have collected debris from several properties before taking the debris to an appropriate facility for disposal and that not all disposal facilities provide printed receipts.  Therefore, where such receipts are not available, Mortgagees will not automatically be denied reimbursement for debris removal.  However, the Department must be able to confirm the type and amount of debris that was removed and that all debris was disposed of properly.  Therefore, Mortgagees must maintain a complete audit trail which will include:  the name, address, and phone number of each company providing the debris removal service, the FHA case number and address of the property, the date of the disposal, the number of cubic yards of debris disposed and a listing of any items that are not ordinary household debris which would include health and safety items, tires, appliances, cars, trucks, boats, batteries, etc.  The documentation must also provide the name, address and telephone number of all disposal facilities used.

 
If a dumpster was brought to the property, the supporting information must identify the date the dumpster was delivered to the property, the date it was removed, and the name, address and telephone number of the company supplying the dumpster. 

Inspections 
The following guidance clarifies the responsibility of a Mortgagee to make an effort to determine occupancy before incurring the expense of a property inspection.  The industry has developed a variety of tools, including the use of “door-hangers” and “mailers” to assist a Mortgagee in determining if a property is occupied or vacant.  These tools ask the occupant to contact the Mortgagee to confirm the occupancy status of the property.  If the occupant fails to respond within the prescribed time period, the mortgagee is required to conduct a prompt visual inspection of the property.

To avoid unnecessary inspections, occupants should be allowed a minimum of five business days from the date of the mailing or other contact to respond to the Mortgagee.  Reimbursement for an occupancy inspection may be denied by the Department if sufficient time is not provided for occupant response.

Lock Change/Securing 
The securing procedures listed in this Mortgagee Letter may be performed without prior approval from the Management and Marketing contractor if all individual expenses remain within the maximum cost allowable for that particular service.   Pest Infestation
This Mortgagee Letter clarifies guidance for the use of over-the-counter products for pest infestations.  If, on the initial inspection, the Mortgagee finds the property to be infested with pests (e.g., roaches, water bugs, mice, rats) that constitute a health or safety hazard or prevent clean‑out or debris removal, the Mortgagee should have the property fumigated by a Pest Control Service, licensed to conduct such business in the area where the property is located.  Insects or vermin that can safely be removed with over-the-counter products do not require professional extermination.  A flea infestation does not require photographic evidence. 

Over-allowable Request Detail
When the cost of work to be completed exceeds the scheduled amount for an individual item, the Mortgagee must request an over-allowable.  All requests to exceed cost limits should include amounts spent to-date on the property so the M&M contractor can determine if the request exceeds the overall cap for preservation and protection and/or if those additional costs are feasible. 

Electronic Submission of Over-allowable Request
Concurrent with the effective date of this Mortgagee Letter, HUD will accept submission of Form HUD-50002, Request to Exceed Cost Limit for Preservation and Protection by mail, fax or electronic (e-mail) formats and will allow M&M contractors to communicate approval or denial of the request by return email.  In the appropriate signature box(s) on the form, the Mortgagee and the M&M contractor shall put the name and contact phone number of the individual authorized to act on behalf of the organization.  An approved or denied copy of the request and supporting documentation must be maintained in the claim review file. 
Limitations on Second Bid Request
With the exception of debris removal, Mortgagees are not required to obtain a second bid for an over-allowable expense if the first bid for the item/service is $250 or less.
When the M&M requests second or revised bids, the M&M contractor will provide a price-range of usual and customary costs, for similar work.   The Mortgagee may request that the M&M provide contact information for those service provider/providers who can do the work for an amount within the usual and customary price-range.  The M&M is familiar with these costs and is required to maintain such records therefore the price-range information should be provided to the mortgagee upon request. 
Upon receipt of two bids for the same scope of work, M&M contractors may not assume that a bid is non-competitive, deny bid approval or request a third bid, solely on the basis that the first and second bids are too close in price. Conversely, Mortgagees should not submit bids that are far apart in price.  If bids are far apart in price the Mortgagee must reconcile the price difference prior to submission to ensure that the bids are based on the same scope of work.  If the bids are based upon the same scope of work, the M&M contractor may request a revised or third bid or provide a not-to-exceed amount that would be acceptable for completion of the work.   
Repair to Heating Systems 
Mortgagee Letter 2007-03 provides in Attachment 7, Section I-B, that if a major repair or replacement is needed to make the heating system operational, the Mortgagee should contact the M&M contractor for instruction.  This language is revised to state, “When there is a jurisdictional requirement for heat to remain on (see local variations in the attachment) and a repair or replacement is needed to make the heating system operational, the Mortgagee should contact the M&M contractor for instructions when the costs of repair is greater than $250.00.”  Mortgagees are required to repair heating systems during winterization season only when there is a jurisdictional requirement for the heat to remain on. Winterization
Mortgagee Letter 2007-03, Attachment 7, required that plumbing and heating systems had to be thoroughly drained.  That language has been revised to state that plumbing and heating systems must be drained in a manner sufficient to prevent freeze and/or other damage.  Demand letters related to winterization will not be issued unless actual damage has occurred.  Permits and Vacant Property Registration Fees
Each Mortgagee and/or field service provider should be familiar with the state and/or jurisdictional requirements related to city ordinances or local law.  If and when a building permit is required by local law prior to performing preservation and protection services, then the Mortgagee must obtain a permit.  If code violations are related to health and safety and/or cost to resolve the violation is less than $250.00 the mortgagee shall complete the work without prior approval from the M&M contractor unless the repair causes mortgagee to exceed the overall cap for preservation and protection.  Otherwise the mortgagee shall contact the M&M contractor.  If the cost for vacant property registration is less than $250.00 the mortgagee shall pay the fee without prior M&M approval and provide documentation of the same in the claim review file.  The fee for vacant property registration should be included as a P&P expense on the claim form HUD-27011.

To view the Mortgagee Letter in its entirety, including several Editorial Revisions and the aforementioned attachments, please click here.

 

About Safeguard
Safeguard Properties is the largest privately held field services company in the country. Located in Cleveland, OH  and founded in 1990 by Robert Klein, Safeguard has grown from a regional preservation company with a few employees and a handful of contractors performing services in the Midwest, to a national company with over 500 employees.  Safeguard is supported by a nationwide network of subcontractors able to perform any requested superintendence, preservation, and maintenance functions, as well as numerous ancillary services in the U.S., the Virgin Islands, and Puerto Rico.